First subscription stuck in inconsistent review state for 6+ weeks, no update after internal escalation

I’m trying to find out whether anyone has seen this kind of App Store Connect issue remain unresolved for this long.

This is for a first auto-renewable subscription.

Timeline:

  • Original support case opened: Feb 27, 2026
  • Support initially repeated the normal guidance that the first subscription must be submitted with the app version
  • I explained that the issue was not the process itself, but a stuck review state
  • On Mar 25, 2026, I was told the case had been escalated to the appropriate internal team
  • Since then, I have sent follow-up emails asking for status / owner / ETA
  • As of Apr 12, 2026 (KST), there has still been no meaningful update

Current state in App Store Connect:

  • App version 1.0.10 is still “Prepare for Submission”
  • Previous 1.0.10 submissions show as “Deleted”
  • There is no active app review submission for 1.0.10
  • The subscription previously showed “Waiting for Review”
  • Now the subscription itself shows “In Review”
  • But its localization still shows “Waiting for Review”

So the state looks inconsistent:

  • no active app review submission
  • app version still draft
  • subscription partially moved into review anyway

At this point I’m not asking about the normal first-subscription submission flow. I already understand that.

What I’m trying to understand is:

  • Has anyone seen a case like this stay stuck for 6+ weeks?
  • Has anyone had Apple say it was escalated internally and then go silent for weeks?
  • Did Apple eventually fix it manually?
  • Is this something that can remain stuck indefinitely unless the internal team intervenes?

Any comparable experience would be helpful.

Unless you show a screenshot from every step of the way from Distribution through individual subscription plans, nobody can probably tell what the problem is that you are facing. I have 2 or 3 new iOS apps with subscription plans that have been approved this year alone. So I haven't faced an issue.

Here are the relevant screenshots.

  1. App Review history: no active review for version 1.0.10, previous submissions are deleted

  1. Subscription page: the subscription itself is now “In Review”

  2. Localization on the same subscription page still shows “Waiting for Review”

  1. App version page: 1.0.10 is still “Prepare for Submission”

That is why I believe the state is inconsistent. The app version is not in review, but the first subscription appears to have partially moved into review anyway.

First subscription stuck in inconsistent review state for 6+ weeks, no update after internal escalation
 
 
Q