Hello everybody!
I’m encountering an unexpected guardrailViolation error when using Foundation Models on macOS Beta 3 (Tahoe) with an Apple M2 Pro chip. This issue didn’t occur on Beta 1 or Beta 2 using the same codebase.
Reproduction Context
I’m developing an app that leverages Foundation Models for structured generation, paired with a local database tool. After upgrading to macOS Beta 3, I started receiving this error consistently, despite no changes in the generation logic.
To isolate the issue, I opened the official WWDC sample project from the Adding intelligent app features with generative models and the same guardrailViolation error appeared without any modifications.
Simplified Working Example
I attempted to narrow down the issue by starting with a minimal prompt structure. This basic case works fine:
import Foundation
import Playgrounds
import FoundationModels
@Generable
struct GeneableLandmark {
@Guide(description: "Name of the landmark to visit")
var name: String
}
final class LandmarkSuggestionGenerator {
var landmarkSuggestion: GeneableLandmark.PartiallyGenerated?
private var session: LanguageModelSession
init(){
self.session = LanguageModelSession(
instructions: Instructions {
"""
generate a list of landmarks to visit
"""
}
)
}
func createLandmarkSuggestion(location: String) async throws {
let stream = session.streamResponse(
generating: GeneableLandmark.self,
options: GenerationOptions(sampling: .greedy),
includeSchemaInPrompt: false
) {
"""
Generate a list of landmarks to viist in \(location)
"""
}
for try await partialResponse in stream {
landmarkSuggestion = partialResponse
}
}
}
#Playground {
let generator = LandmarkSuggestionGenerator()
Task {
do {
try await generator.createLandmarkSuggestion(location: "New york")
if let suggestion = generator.landmarkSuggestion {
print("Suggested landmark: \(suggestion)")
} else {
print("No suggestion generated.")
}
} catch {
print("Error generating landmark suggestion: \(error)")
}
}
}
But as soon as I use the Sample ItineraryPlanner:
#Playground {
// Example landmark for demonstration
let exampleLandmark = Landmark(
id: 1,
name: "San Francisco",
continent: "North America",
description: "A vibrant city by the bay known for the Golden Gate Bridge.",
shortDescription: "Iconic Californian city.",
latitude: 37.7749,
longitude: -122.4194,
span: 0.2,
placeID: nil
)
let planner = ItineraryPlanner(landmark: exampleLandmark)
Task {
do {
try await planner.suggestItinerary(dayCount: 3)
if let itinerary = planner.itinerary {
print("Suggested itinerary: \(itinerary)")
} else {
print("No itinerary generated.")
}
} catch {
print("Error generating itinerary: \(error)")
}
}
}
The error pops up:
Multiline
Error generating itinerary:
guardrailViolation(FoundationModels.LanguageModelSession. >GenerationError.Context(debug
Description: "May contain sensitive or unsafe content", >underlyingErrors:
[FoundationModels. LanguageModelSession. Gene >rationError.guardrailViolation(FoundationMo dels. >LanguageModelSession.GenerationError.C ontext (debugDescription: >"May contain unsafe content", underlyingErrors: []))]))
Based on my tests:
The error may not be tied to structure complexity (since more nested structures work)
The issue may stem from the tools or prompt content used inside the ItineraryPlanner
The guardrail sensitivity may have increased or changed in Beta 3, affecting models that worked in earlier betas
Thank you in advance for your help. Let me know if more details or reproducible code samples are needed - I’m happy to provide them.
Best,
Sasha Morozov
